Carol's Journey

In Carol’s Journey, Carol fought conventionalism by her stubbornness. For her age, she was wise of the world matters, knew she was loved and was confident in herself. She spoke fluent Spanish and English, she defended herself against being bullied, and had a charming way of persuading others to believe in what was right. I would have liked to see the end of the movie. I thought Carol was independent which interfered with her efforts to adapt to her new culture. She did not like being controlled by her Aunt when she lived with them. Carol returned to the US after her mother died, which she handled very well, and the death of a new friend. Her dad meant everything to her. I think the men realized not to shoot the father but killed her friend as an example that the Military is in charge. I wondered if the American man was really Carol’s father because her mother said she had to leave Spain because she was pregnant.

Volver

In Volver, the plot is filled with murder, a mother who you are not sure is a ghost or not, and a daughter trying to escape her past. I thought the movie was bizarre and left me asking myself, what was the meaning of this movie? I would have to say it was the love these women had for one another. Relationships grew apart, then stronger due to the love, adultery, incest and murder that revolved around these women’s lives. Raimunda was so upset at her husband (due to her past) when she hears that her daughter was being violated by him. She was willing to take the blame for his death’ to protect Paula. We find out in the movie that Paula is really Raimunda’s sister, due to her being violated by her father. Raimunda seems to be reliving past experiences. These women through the good and bad times come together and share secrets. These secrets bond them together. Raimunda eventually sees her mother and hears of her own story as she used the fire she set to pretend she was dead. I believe this is a tribute to women to show how they bond, grieve, love and keep one another’s secrets.

The tension between superstitious beliefs I believe is caused by whether on is willing to accept the superstition or goes against it. The person or persons who believe have tension when others don’t understand or give the superstition importance. Raimunda thought Augustina was crazy for asking her to ask her mother something for her if she saw her. Everyone “knew” her mother was dead. Also the cleaning of the tombstones was a superstition. All of the women were at the cemetery in the windy city to take care of the tombstones.

Sandy Clark

Entre Nos

In this true life story, Mariana and her children are abandoned by her husband. They are left with very little money. Mariana realizes she will have to make money to support them. She makes and tries to sell her empanadas but is unsuccessful at first. They also would not let her go to certain jobs because of the children with her. Mariana knew she needed to make money but her first priority was her children. She would let them sleep and eat before she did. She kept them safe. Gabriel, the son, took on a responsible role. He was the caregiver when his mother went to find work. He was the breadwinner when his mother was sick. Mariana taught both the children the courage and endurance to go on with life regardless what challenges you are facing. They never seemed to whine or complain. Even when there was only enough money for one snack, Gabriel let his sister pick and he did not get his chocolate bar. The children would get up early with their mother and start collecting cans from the city garbage just to earn money. The children were excited at the amount of cans they found. Gabriel even wanted to finish their work for the day (counting cans), before they ate lunch. Gabriel seemed sad at first and did not talk much but after realizing his dad was not returning, he seemed to mature even more. He speaks English and was able to translate when his mother did not understand. I thought this was a wonderful movie. The perseverance Mariana showed to her children is that you can succeed no matter what you are facing.

The Official Story

I thought the end of this movie was disturbing. I did not like the violence that occurred as a result of Alicia pushing for the truth. Then the movie left you hanging with an unknown ending. I think Alicia will be able to reconcile with personal thoughts due to her determination to pursue the truth. If she had not pursued in finding if Gaby’s birth parents were prisoners of war, I don’t think she would have been able to forgive herself. She asked the priest for guidance and did not really get any reassurance, even implying that he knew what Roberto did and this made the priest uncomfortable. She was asked not to ever bring the subject up with Roberto but she could not get away from the pressure of the subject due to the students in class and the marching of the families who had someone taken. She even supported the student’s opinion in his paper if he placed the references. She had her mind open to the possibility that Gaby could have been one of the children taken at birth.

I hope that Alicia did not return to her husband. When she walked out at the end of the movie, I think that was symbolic that she was thru with him. If the natural grandmother pursued a relationship with Gaby, I feel Alicia would have allowed this. Alicia could lose custody of Gaby but I think she was willing to pay that price for the truth. She did not want Gaby to grow up not knowing the truth. I think Gaby was wiser that her age, even though she acted like a baby at times. She sang a song. This did not sound like nor did the words seem to be a children’s lullaby. She always sang it, like she was trying to express herself so they would understand her or remember her. Possibly she heard at birth before she was taken.